Afraid of Disappointing People? The 3-Question Check We Use Before Speaking Up

By Louie & Michael. Not therapists, just two guys in therapy.
Guide · From episode #153, "The Scariest Thing is Being a Disappointment"

Quick answer: For a lot of people, being a disappointment feels dangerous, not just uncomfortable. If love felt conditional growing up, "I'm disappointed in you" can land like "I'm about to leave." So you keep the peace, swallow the opinion, and call it being easygoing. The fear is learned. It isn't proof that people will actually leave.

Our version, in one line: it's not that disappointment hurts. It's that it feels like the first step out the door.

Why it can feel like abandonment

Disappointment is a normal part of any close relationship. People let each other down, say so, and stay. But if, as a kid, someone's approval was what kept you safe, your brain may have filed "they're upset with me" under threat.

That's why a small comment can set off a big reaction. You're not reacting to the comment. You're reacting to what it used to mean.

It's closely related to fawning: becoming whoever keeps the other person happy, so the conflict never starts.

Signs this might be you

  • You'd rather swallow an opinion than risk someone being upset with you.

  • When someone is disappointed in you, it feels like a verdict on your whole character.

  • You can't tell which disagreements are a big deal and which aren't, so you treat them all as a big deal.

  • When you're disappointed in someone, you don't say it. You just quietly keep score.

  • You feel happiest when the people around you are pleased with you.

  • Compliments are hard to believe.

What it sounded like for us

This was a Halloween episode. We drew cards with uncomfortable questions on them, one of us was dressed as a Diet Coke can, and it still got heavy.

Louie had recently told Michael he was disappointed in him. When it came up:

"It feels like it speaks to my character and it feels like the path to abandonment."
— Michael · 1:01:36

And then, half-joking:

"How many more of those do I get before you go?"
— Michael · 1:01:56

It works the other way too. When Michael's the disappointed one, he doesn't say it. He pushes it down so he doesn't rock the boat.

"You bury it alive."
— Louie · 1:02:49

Earlier, a card asked when we'd seen each other genuinely happy. The answer was hard to hear:

"Your happiness is a product of performance. Some might say people pleasing. When people are pleased with you, you're happy because you know you're safe."
— Louie · 41:36

And the question that stuck with us both:

"Do you want someone in your life that disappoints you and then when you voice it they say [forget] you and leave?"
— Louie · 1:03:32

The honest answer was no. Which kind of answers the whole thing.

The 3-question check

Michael said the hardest part is that everything feels high-risk (1:04:59). So he's started running a quick check in conversations before deciding whether to speak up. Louie suggested swapping "risk" for "consequence" (1:05:20), because that's what it really is.

1. Is this high consequence or low consequence? A friend's opinion about whether guys over 40 should wear jeans? Low. Something about how they treat you? Maybe high. Most things are lower than they feel.

2. Do I actually agree with this? Not "will they be upset if I don't," but what you think. If you don't know yet, that's an answer too.

3. Does this belong to me? Some opinions, rules, and "you shoulds" are someone else's. You don't have to carry them. The two-word version:

"Says you."
— Michael · 1:06:05

"So that's the gambit I'm running in conversations now."
— Michael · 1:08:01

If it's low consequence and doesn't belong to you, you can let it go, for real this time, not by burying it. If it's high consequence and it matters to you, that's when it's worth saying something. When Louie asked why he finally brought something up after a show:

"It's worth it."
— Michael · 1:08:53

What to say (scripts)

We wrote these. Use them, change them, make them sound like you.

When you're disappointed in someone:

  • "Hey, I want to bring something up, and it's not a big deal, I'm just practicing saying things out loud. I was disappointed when ___."

  • "I'm not mad. I was let down, and I'd rather tell you than keep score."

When someone tells you they're disappointed in you:

  • "Thanks for telling me. Give me a minute with that before I respond."

  • "Are we good, or is this a bigger thing?" (Asking beats guessing.)

When you notice you're about to swallow an opinion:

  • "I actually see it a little differently."

  • "Huh. Says you." (Best used with friends who know the bit.)

When you're not sure yet:

  • "Let me think about that and get back to you." You're allowed to not have the answer on the spot.

What has helped us (not advice)

  • Saying it in low-stakes moments first. Practice on jeans before you practice on the big stuff.

  • Noticing who stays. Every time someone hears "I'm disappointed" and doesn't leave, that's evidence. Collect it.

  • Asking instead of predicting. "Are you upset with me?" is scary to ask. Guessing is usually worse.

  • Therapy. We both go. Michael is starting to look at masking for the first time. It helps to have someone who can tell you what "safe" actually feels like.

Sources and further reading

  • John Bowlby's attachment theory, starting with Attachment and Loss, Vol. 1: Attachment (1969). It's the research behind how early relationships shape what feels "safe."

  • Our glossary post: What Is Fawning?

  • If you want to talk to someone: find a therapist or try a sponsor of the show, BetterHelp

Listen

Episode #153 on YouTube. Yes, it's a Halloween episode. Yes, one of us is a bear. The after-show is on Patreon.

Related

We're not therapists. Just two guys in therapy, sharing what we've learned the hard way. If you're struggling, talk to a professional. In the US, call or text 988 any time.

Previous
Previous

The Daily Page: A Free Printable for People Who Hate That Self-Care Takes Discipline

Next
Next

Love or Control? A Very Unscientific Quiz